Sales comparison, cost and income capitalization: learn how the three approaches to value work, how appraisers reconcile them, and how an appraisal differs from a CMA in Florida.
The three approaches to value are the sales comparison approach, the cost approach and the income capitalization approach. An appraiser uses at least one of them, often more, and then weighs the results to reach a single opinion of a property’s value.
This topic matters if you are studying for a Florida real estate license, and it helps if you are a buyer or seller wondering what a lender’s appraisal involves.
Ready to start your Florida license? Our 63-hour Florida sales associate pre-license course covers appraisal, CMA vs. BPO and much more. Course exams are included, no extra fees.
The three approaches to value at a glance
Think of the approaches as three different questions an appraiser can ask about the same property. According to the Appraisal Institute’s consumer guidance, appraisers typically use at least one of them.
| Approach | The question it asks | Often a good fit for | Core idea |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sales comparison | What did similar homes nearby sell for? | Typical homes in areas with plenty of recent sales | Compare to recent sales, then adjust for differences |
| Cost | What would it cost to build this property, minus wear and tear? | New or proposed construction, renovations, unique properties | Land value + cost new − depreciation |
| Income capitalization | What income can this property earn? | Rental and investment properties; required by Fannie Mae when valuing two- to four-unit properties. | Value = NOI ÷ cap rate |
What does “value” mean here? The Fannie Mae Selling Guide (B4-1.1-01) defines market value as the most probable price a property should bring in a competitive and open market, with a prudent, knowledgeable buyer and seller and no undue stimulus.

The sales comparison approach
This is the approach most buyers and sellers see. The appraiser compares the home’s condition, construction, and features with recent sales of similar homes nearby. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide requires at least three closed comparable sales to be reported.
Why adjustments matter
No two homes are identical, so the appraiser adjusts each comparable for differences. Under Fannie Mae’s guidance (B4-1.3-09), adjustments must reflect how the market actually reacts to a difference, not a rule-of-thumb number. Sales or financing concessions, such as closing costs paid by the seller, must be analyzed and adjusted when they affect the comparable property’s sale price. Adjustments should reflect the market’s reaction to the concessions rather than automatically deducting their full stated amount.
Example (hypothetical numbers): A comparable sold for $400,000 and has a larger garage than the subject home. If the market shows buyers pay about $10,000 more for that garage, the appraiser adjusts the comparable down to $390,000.
The cost approach appraisal
The cost approach asks what it would cost to buy an equivalent lot and build the same house, then subtracts depreciation. Fannie Mae’s Selling Guide (B4-1.3-10) says it may suit new or proposed construction, property being renovated, unique property, or property with functional depreciation.
The standard textbook formula is:
- Value = land value + cost new (replacement or reproduction) − accrued depreciation
Replacement cost generally means building an equally useful property with modern materials. Reproduction cost means building an exact replica. Depreciation can come from physical wear, functional problems (such as an awkward layout) or outside factors.
The income capitalization approach
The income approach assumes a property’s value is related to the income it can be expected to earn. The Appraisal Institute notes it is often used for investment or rental properties, and Fannie Mae requires it for two- to four-unit properties.
The standard direct capitalization formulas are:
- Value = net operating income (NOI) ÷ capitalization rate
- NOI = effective gross income − operating expenses
Example (hypothetical numbers): A small rental property earns an NOI of $30,000 a year. With a market cap rate of 6% (0.06), the indicated value is $30,000 ÷ 0.06 = $500,000. You divide by the cap rate; you do not multiply.
When the income approach is used on a loan appraisal, Fannie Mae also expects comparable rental data and gross rent multiplier (GRM) calculations. In simple terms, a GRM relates a property’s rent to its price.

Studying for the Florida exam? Practice matching each approach to a scenario with our Florida sales associate state exam prep. Our instructors are available Monday–Friday, 9am–7pm ET, and course exams are included, no extra fees.
Reconciliation: how appraisers reach one number
After using the approaches, the appraiser reconciles the results into a final opinion. Under Fannie Mae’s guidance (B4-1.3-11), that means weighing the reliability of each approach and reporting which received the most weight.
Reconciliation is never a simple average, except a properly explained weighted average, and the final value must fall within the range the approaches indicated. Fannie Mae also does not accept appraisals relying solely on the cost or income approach, and USPAP requires any approach needed for credible results.
How a home appraisal works, step by step
- The lender orders it. The lender typically arranges the appraisal, and the borrower may be responsible for the appraisal fee. Lenders commonly charge this fee after the borrower indicates an intention to proceed with the mortgage application.
- The appraiser reviews the property and gathers comparable sales and, when relevant, cost or rental data.
- The approaches are applied and reconciled into a written report with a final value opinion.
- The borrower gets a copy. For a typical first-lien mortgage, the lender must provide the borrower with a free copy of the appraisal promptly after completion and no later than three business days before closing, unless the borrower validly waives the timing requirement.
Appraisal vs. CMA in Florida
Agents often prepare a comparative market analysis (CMA) to help set a listing price. It is useful, but it is not an appraisal, and Florida law is explicit about that.
| Appraisal | CMA | |
|---|---|---|
| Who can issue it | Only a certified or licensed appraiser | A broker or sales associate, in the ordinary course of business |
| Florida law | F.S. 475.612(1): only certified or licensed appraisers may issue an appraisal report | F.S. 475.612(3): may never be referred to or construed as an appraisal |
| Typical use | Often ordered by a lender in a mortgage transaction | Helping sellers and buyers think about pricing |
Read the exact wording in Florida Statutes section 475.612. The takeaway for agents: never call your CMA or price opinion an appraisal.
Florida real estate exam appraisal: what to expect
The FREC exam outline includes a “Real Estate Appraisal” section worth 8%, covering USPAP, market value, the three approaches, CMA and broker price opinion (BPO). The DBPR Candidate Information Booklet describes the exam as 100 questions over 3.5 hours, with 75 needed to pass. Memorize the three formulas and know how a CMA, BPO and appraisal differ.
Not licensed yet? In Florida you must be at least 18, hold a high school diploma or equivalent, have a U.S. Social Security number, complete a 63-hour pre-licensing course (valid for two years) and submit fingerprints. The DBPR currently lists a total application and licensing fee of $83.75 for a Florida sales associate. This includes a $14.75 nonrefundable application fee, a $64 license fee, and a $5 unlicensed activity fee. Applicants should verify current fees through DBPR and check Pearson VUE for examination fees and scheduling information. Our guide to becoming a Florida Realtor walks through the path, and our real estate exam prep guide covers study strategy.

Frequently asked questions
What are the three approaches to value?
They are the sales comparison, cost and income capitalization approaches. Appraisers use at least one and reconcile them into a final value opinion.
Can an appraiser use just one approach?
It depends on what is needed for a credible result. Fannie Mae will not accept appraisals that rely solely on the cost or income approach.
Is a CMA the same as an appraisal?
No. In Florida, only certified or licensed appraisers may issue appraisal reports, and an agent’s CMA or price opinion can never be construed as an appraisal (F.S. 475.612).
Who orders the appraisal?
On a mortgage, the lender does. Buyers generally are not allowed to shop for the appraiser.
What if the appraisal comes in low?
You may renegotiate, bring more cash, cancel (depending on your contract) or request a reconsideration of value. See the CFPB’s guidance on a low appraisal.
Does the Florida real estate exam cover appraisal?
Yes. The Real Estate Appraisal section is worth 8% of the exam outline.
Take the next step toward your Florida license
Knowing the three approaches to value gives you a head start on the state exam and on real client conversations. MLS Campus has helped students since 2014. We are a FREC-approved school (DBPR school license ZH1002474), instructors are available Monday–Friday, 9am–7pm ET, and course exams are included, no extra fees.
Explore our Florida real estate courses or visit MLS Campus to get started.
For education only; not legal, financial or appraisal advice. Formulas are standard textbook versions and example numbers are hypothetical.
Ready to get your Florida real estate license?
Study online at your own pace with state-approved, instructor-supported courses. Browse the Florida packages or head back to our homepage to explore everything MLS Campus offers.