The landscape of real estate commissions is undergoing a monumental shift. Recent changes, particularly the NAR settlement updates, have significantly impacted how commissions are structured, negotiated, and protected. For agents and clients alike, understanding these changes is vital to navigating the evolving real estate market. From new buyer-broker agreements to stricter guidelines on seller concessions and procuring cause, agents need to be well-versed in these updates to safeguard their earnings and remain competitive.
This blog will break down the 2025 commission updates, explaining how the NAR settlement affects commission rates, arbitration, and negotiations. We will also provide guidance on how agents can protect their earnings through the procuring cause doctrine, ensuring their commission claims are solid in the face of disputes. With these insights, both agents and clients can approach commission discussions with a clearer understanding of their rights and opportunities.
Section 1: The Evolution of Real Estate Commissions
Key NAR Settlement Changes Effective 2024-2025
Historically, real estate commissions in the USA have been anchored by the 5-6% commission split, with the buyer’s and seller’s agents typically splitting the fee. However, the Sitzer-Burnett lawsuits, culminating in the $418 million NAR settlement, are reshaping this model. Finalized on November 27, 2024, this settlement addresses the way commissions are disclosed and negotiated within the industry.
One of the most significant changes is the requirement for written buyer-broker agreements, effective from August 17, 2024. These agreements ensure greater transparency by requiring agents and buyers to agree on commission structures upfront. This move aims to protect both parties by clearly outlining commission expectations and preventing misunderstandings.
Another key change involves the prohibition of seller concessions for buyer-agent fees on MLS listings. Previously, sellers could automatically offer to cover buyer-agent fees through their listing on the MLS. Under the new rules, these fees must now be negotiated directly between the buyer and the buyer’s agent, ensuring that commissions remain negotiable and eliminating potential conflicts of interest. This brings a new level of transparency to the industry, benefiting both agents and clients.
Finally, the emphasis on negotiable commissions reflects the growing trend of flexible pricing models in real estate. With the rise of flat-fee services and commission negotiations, the traditional 6% commission structure is gradually being replaced by more customized arrangements, depending on the services provided and market conditions.
MLS Restrictions and Negotiation Trends
As MLS restrictions come into effect, buyers and agents will no longer rely on standardized commission offers from sellers. The traditional practice of listing buyer-agent fees in the MLS has been eliminated, forcing agents to engage in direct negotiations with buyers. This opens up opportunities for innovative commission models, such as performance-based fees and tiered pricing based on the services provided. Agents are increasingly adopting flexible compensation strategies to adapt to these changes. Explore more about commission negotiation trends.
Section 2: 2025 Nationwide Law Updates and Impacts
National Real Estate Commission Rate Changes
Despite predictions of a decline in commissions, average total commissions in 2025 remain near historical norms, averaging between 5.39% and 5.57% nationally. In fact, some regions have seen slight increases in commissions, such as the 2.43% buyer-agent commission, up from 2.38% in 2024. This increase may reflect the rising value of buyer-agent services as more buyers engage agents for a wider range of services, including negotiation and property research.
However, states like New Jersey and California continue to see variations in commission rates, with New Jersey’s average at 4.92%. These differences can be attributed to local market dynamics, competitive pressures, and regulatory environments. For example, New York and California tend to have higher commission rates due to the complexity and competitive nature of these markets, while states like Florida and Illinois show slight declines in average commission percentages.
| Region | 2024 Average Commission | 2025 Projected Commission |
| National | 5.39%-5.57% | 5.39%-5.57% |
| New Jersey | 4.90% | 4.92% |
| Florida | 5.5% | 5.4% |
| California | 5.8% | 5.7% |
These statistics demonstrate the impact of regional market conditions on commission structures. States with higher property values or a larger volume of transactions, like California, tend to maintain higher commission rates compared to states with lower average home prices.
Impact of NAR Ethics Amendments
The NAR Code of Ethics amendments, effective June 5, 2025, include 11 updated Standards of Practice focusing on transparency and fair dealing. These updates ensure that agents provide full disclosure of their commission structures to clients, allowing for more transparent and ethical business practices. Read more about the NAR Code of Ethics updates here.
Section 3: Commission & Procuring Cause: Safeguarding Your Earnings
What Constitutes Procuring Cause?
The procuring cause doctrine is vital in determining an agent’s entitlement to commission. In real estate, procuring cause refers to the uninterrupted chain of events initiated by an agent’s efforts that directly lead to the sale of a property. For example, suppose an agent shows a property to a buyer who later purchases it. In that case, the agent may be entitled to a commission, provided the agent’s efforts directly contributed to the sale.
To establish procuring cause, the following criteria must be met:
- Continuous efforts: The agent’s involvement must have been continuous, without any abandonment or interruption.
- Direct involvement: The agent must have played a direct role in bringing the transaction to completion, such as showing the property, facilitating negotiations, or helping with the closing process.
- No breaks in service: If the agent’s involvement was interrupted by a significant event, such as willful abandonment or a change of agent, the right to commission may be forfeited.
The doctrine of procuring cause is often cited in commission disputes, and understanding its parameters is crucial for safeguarding commissions in contentious transactions. For further clarification on NAR’s arbitration rules, check out NAR’s arbitration guidelines.
Strategies to Avoid Procuring Cause Disputes
To safeguard their commission, real estate agents should take proactive steps:
- Document everything: Keep detailed records of all communications, showings, and negotiations.
- Maintain exclusive agreements: Secure exclusive buyer-broker agreements to ensure a right to commission.
- Regular updates: Keep clients informed at each step of the process to avoid misunderstandings.
In disputes over procuring cause, agents who have documented their actions and maintained clear communication with clients will be in a stronger position to protect their earnings.
Section 4: Practical Advice for Agents and Clients
Digital Tools and Transparency
To remain competitive in the evolving commission landscape, agents can use digital tools to track interactions, manage buyer-broker agreements, and ensure transparency. Tools such as CRM software and commission tracking apps can help agents maintain organized records and streamline their processes. Additionally, agents should make use of online platforms that facilitate direct negotiations with clients, allowing both parties to agree on terms more easily.
Negotiation Tips
For agents, it’s crucial to be prepared for negotiations. Offering flexible commission structures can help meet the needs of clients, especially when dealing with higher-end properties or first-time buyers who may be unfamiliar with commission practices. For clients, understanding how commissions work and negotiating upfront can help prevent confusion during the transaction.
Navigating the world of real estate commissions in 2025 requires a thorough understanding of the new NAR regulations, procuring cause principles, and evolving market trends. Agents must remain adaptable, using tools for transparency and documenting their efforts to safeguard their earnings. As commission structures become more flexible and negotiable, agents who stay informed and proactive will be best positioned to thrive in this new environment.
For more detailed information on NAR settlement updates, refer to the NAR Settlement FAQ. If you’re an agent, consulting with legal experts or exploring more on Realtor.com can provide further guidance on commission negotiation.
By understanding these critical changes, both agents and clients can approach real estate transactions with greater clarity and confidence.
FAQ – Real Estate Commissions in the USA
- What are the new changes regarding real estate commissions?
The National Association of Realtors (NAR) settlement finalized in November 2024, which brought major changes. As of August 17, 2024, real estate commissions became negotiable, and written buyer-broker agreements became mandatory. Additionally, MLS restrictions now prohibit seller concessions for buyer agent fees. These modifications aim to make commission structures more transparent and flexible.
- What does “procuring cause” mean in real estate?
Procuring cause refers to the uninterrupted chain of events initiated by a real estate agent’s efforts that directly lead to a property sale. If disputes over commission arise, determining who is the procuring cause—based on factors like showing the property, negotiating the deal, or securing the buyer—is crucial in commission arbitration.
- Are commission rates still the same across the USA in 2025?
No, commission rates vary by region and brokerage. On average, total commissions in the USA are now between 5.39% and 5.57%, with regional variations. For example, in New Jersey, the rate is about 4.92%. The 6% commission model is on the decline, as more buyers and sellers opt for flat-fee or negotiated commissions.
- How does the NAR 2025 Code of Ethics affect real estate professionals?
The NAR’s updated Code of Ethics, effective June 5, 2025, includes 11 new Standards of Practice focused on transparency, fairness, and ethics in real estate transactions. These changes reflect the industry’s shift toward more equitable and transparent commission practices.
- Can I still earn a commission if the sale does not close?
Yes, you can still earn a commission if certain conditions are met. For example, if a seller rejects a qualified offer or cancels the sale without a valid reason, the agent may still be entitled to compensation based on the agreement. A “Ready, Willing, and Able Buyer” clause often guarantees this right.
- What is the future of the 6% commission structure?
The 6% commission model is expected to continue its decline as more sellers and buyers explore negotiation options and flat-fee services. Many industry experts predict further fragmentation in commission structures as transparency increases and buyer-broker agreements gain prominence.
- How can agents safeguard their earnings under the new rules?
Agents should always have clear, documented agreements, such as buyer-broker agreements, to ensure their commissions are protected. Keeping detailed records of all communications and actions can help in the event of a commission dispute, particularly regarding the “procuring cause.”
- What if multiple brokers are involved in a commission dispute?
In cases of broker-to-broker commission disputes, the resolution typically involves arbitration or mediation. Both parties are encouraged to resolve disagreements amicably before pursuing legal action. NAR’s dispute resolution processes, including mediation, aim to prevent costly and public legal battles.
- Is commission negotiation a common practice?
Yes, commission rates are now widely negotiable, especially with the implementation of the NAR settlement. Brokers are no longer allowed to impose uniform rates. Negotiations between brokers and clients have become more common, leading to more flexible commission structures that can be tailored to individual transactions.
- How do I learn more about commission disputes and procuring cause?
For more detailed guidance, real estate professionals should consult resources like the NAR Settlement FAQ and consider seeking legal advice to navigate complex commission issues. Also, checking out articles from trusted industry sources, like Realtor.com, can provide additional insight into current trends and best practices.
Customer Support: Call us at (877) 331-6235 or Contact us by Email
If we can assist you with Technical Support, General License Inquiries or Questions about Course Material please contact us.
Questions about course material: An Instructor is available Monday through Friday a week from 9 am to 7 pm (EST)
Technical Support or any other questions: Our office staff are available Monday through Friday a week from 9 am to 7 pm (EST)
We do our best to reply promptly to emails on Weekends
*Except for Major Holidays
Join Over 100,000 Students Enroll With MLS Campus now
Become Part of MLS Campus School to Further Your Career.